Make wood stain? Is it just spilling coffee or tea on a wood table?
Actually … no! There’s way more amazing stuff to it!
Made from all natural household materials, these quick and easy DIY wood stains are super effective, long lasting, and very low cost! And they are better for our planet as well – no solvents and no VOCs !
Since I wrote the original post a couple of years ago, lots of readers have share their experiences and new recipes. This completely updated version will include the following 4 parts:
1 . Why these wood stains work, and what is the science behind these durable wood stains.
2 . 7 easy recipes to make your own natural wood stains in any color.
3 . Pros and cons of DIY wood stains vs store bought wood stains
4 . Helpful tips and our reader’s FAQs
The first 4 basic recipes are various mixtures of vinegar and metal. Why?
Let’s start with a little bit of science behind these effective wood stains.
The iron dissolves in the vinegar (acetic acid) and forms a soluble substance (iron acetate). When this solution is applied to wood, the iron acetate reacts with the natural tannins in the wood, producing various shades of brown, grey and black.
As you can see, it is a chemical reaction, which is durable indoors and outdoors, vs when you hear “coffee stain”, “tea stain” or “beet juice stain” on wood, those are in fact natural dyes that would fade away quickly in sunlight.
Now our four basic recipes. I started with 4 jars to test various types of vinegar and metal: ( Some of the helpful resources are affiliate links. Full disclosure here. )
Recipe 1. 1 1/2 cup of white vinegar and one steel wool pad
Recipe 2. 1 1/2 cup of balsamic vinegar and one steel wool pad
Recipe 3. 1 1/2 cup of apple cider vinegar and one steel wool pad
Recipe 4. 1 1/2 cup of white vinegar and rusty nails
You must be thinking: “Oh balsamic vinegar will be the darkest stain, due to its color! ”
Want to bet $1000? =)
To make the stains, put a super fine steel wool pad (or rusty nails as in the 4th recipe ) in the jar and pour in enough vinegar to cover it, loosely put the lid on the jar to allow for air exchange when the reaction is happening- see photo below. If the pad is not totally submersed, rust will quickly form on the portion exposed to air which is ok.
After about twenty-four hours pour the solution into another jar, or take the pads out of the jars to stop the reaction.
All the steel wool pads have shrunk to about 1/2 the size! Leaving them in the jar longer will produce a darker stain. The variations are endless!
Now watch the magic! When I first brushed some of this wood stain onto a piece of wood, I thought nothing was happening! But a few minutes later, it looks all different, wow!
As you can see in the picture below, the stain colors has nothing to do with the vinegar color! Balsamic vinegar and steel wood solution is in the middle, but the white vinegar and steel wood solution on the left has the deepest color. The photo was take 5 minutes after the stain was applied.
Before we look at all the colors in comparison, let’s look at two more variations on these 4 basic wood stains. Continue To Next Page…
Wow! Such a cool post. This is so interesting!
http://www.MariaProvenzano.com
What awesome ideas! I had no idea!
Wow! What a creative and cool idea! I had no clue you could do this. Love it 🙂
thank you reichel! =)
Such a great idea! I love that there are no chemicals involved, and that I have all of this stuff in my garage!
isn’t it odd that we make simple things toxic when it becomes commercial? 😉
What a lovely Person to share such great stuff. I am off to the garage straight away – totally inspired thank-you!
Ooh wow! Thanks for the tips!
Wow, what an impressive post. I always admire someone who conducts research for such projects. Thank you for all the great information. Cheers, Ardith
thank you ardith for appreciating the geeky side of me! =)
I have used the steel wool w/ white vinegar before. It worked but there was a lot of residue (probably rust) on the wood that had to be wiped off after it dried. Once I got all that off I just proceeded as if I was using regular stain. I like these methods particularly for signs etc that are going to have a distressed layer of paint over them.
thank you so much karen for sharing your great tips! i did notice the residue too, need to add that in the article! =)
And the residue only appears AFTER applying it? What if you passed it through a filter of sorts beforehand?
the residue is super fine, a filter may help a little, there will likely still be some =)
Anada,
You are brilliant! Thanks so much for sharing your creativity!
Happy day friend!
karianne
thank you dear karianne! xoxo
Amazing post dear!
http://www.bloglovin.com/blogs/printed-sea-3880191
http://mydiyol.blogspot.de
Hello Ananda,
this is a great post!
Thank you for sharing!
many greetings
Uwe
P.S.: I have a new blog!
please visit
hey uwe! your new blog looks great! =) tried to comment but it gave me the problem massage again!
What a great tutorial for different kinds of natural stains! I love how you showed so many comparison photos!! I’m pinning this so I don’t forget!
Great idea, thanks for sharing, I will be putting this to test =)
Thank you for answering so many of my questions about these methods! 🙂 I still can’t get it to “brew” in a jar, I have to make it in an open bowl. So far, this is the only way that seems to be working!?!
hi tess! that’s odd… but if an open bowl works, you can always pour the liquid into a jar to store it, right? just make sure to take out the metal to stop reaction! xx
It’s just a WOW technique. Appreciate. A natural way of making wood stains and that’s also a non-toxic, really fantastic. Considering the way it is made, the results expected will definitely be a hit. Given recipes are good. Enjoy.
Wow thank you for such a great post! I’m looking into staining my outdoor fence, is this type of wood stain suitable for outdoor? Will it fade from harsh sunlight or rain?
Thanks 🙂
hi crystal, yes it is suitable for outdoor and have been used in history! =)
I have used these stain to great effect. I have also used a mixture of white vinegar and hydrogen peroxide and copper to make beautiful carribean blue stain. I had the best luck when I heated up the liquids to near boiling in the microwave then added copper wire and let it sit for about an hour. Do not use pennies, they are not made from copoer anymore.
thank you so much Roy! i was soaking copper pennies in vinegar and nothing happened! will try your tips for sure!! =)
What were the proportions you used to make the hydrogen peroxide, vinegar and copper stain?
I’m no chemist but I understand that Hydrogen Peroxide can be volatile when in a concentrated form (ie less diluted) so you might want to be careful when heating it. Anyone else know more? David
How exactly is rust residue “non-toxic”?
hi kerry, many of the products used to coat wood around the home have traditionally contained volatile organic solvents and other toxic chemicals. these home-made stains are water based, and the colors come from tannins in the wood reacting with metals like iron dissolved in vinegar, it’s not rust sitting on top. hope that helps! =)
how would you make a gray or red stain
i would use method #7- diluted paint. 🙂
I didn’t know it could be so simple. I have a question though – will woodstain made this way provide any protection for the wood or is it just for colouring?
hi neil, it’s for coloring. oils and sealers would be used for extra protection.
Thank you so much for sharing! I did a pre-stain with coffee and food coloring and then a final coat of steel wool dissolved in about 2 1/2 cups of white vinegar and 3 tablespoons of balsamic and ended up with a BEAUTIFUL rich espresso color!
thank you lydia for sharing!! =)
This is a wonderful thing you’ve shown! Thank you so much !
About the diluted paint/stain – I did something on the spur of the moment once and it tuerned out amazing . I had a couple teaspoons of reddish-brown paint left in the bottom of the can after painting outside of my house and I had a really ugly stone wishing well in the yard , made of faded whitish grey stones and I added water1/2 way up the almost empty paint can and sloshed it around and then painted it onto the ugly wishing well thinking it might not last but would be better for awhile .
Surprise .. it stained the stones a beautiful reddish sandstone color that’s still nice 2 yrs. later !
thank you so much for sharing !! =)
Awesome!! Thanks for sharing. I will be starting this tomorrow. I have several pallets with some diy ideas. Dreaded paying 12.00 for a little bit of stain especially when I need different colors for my project. I’m super excited to try this method. Definitely safer for our environment.. I have all the items needed..
you will love homemade wood stain Shelly! =)
Does the stain color in the jar darken once you take the pass out? I have had the steel pads in the vinegar for almost 48 hours because I feel like it’s not darkening up…
it won’t darken much in white vinegar, but it will stain effectively! =)
quiero teñir una mesita de café, después de teñir, se le puede dar algún tipo de barniz, para proteger y que no queden manchas de café o cualquier liquido que pueda caer.
yes i would use some kind of natural non-toxic varnish or sealer to protect the table! =)
LOVE! Does this tend to dry pretty quickly?
yes they dry very quickly =)
Love the shades that have come up on the wood , it is really awesome. most important it is non toxic. Thanks Ananda for the tip.
Will look forward for much stuff.
I have my steel wool in a jar with vinegar but it isn’t working ?
oh! what kind of wood? try a drop on a piece of white paper, the stain should color the paper in 5 minutes. if so, then it’s the wood!
marvelous post!
I enjoyed it a lot. I will try some combinations… thank you from Portugal
Seakestrel
thank you luis! =)
can I use metal scrubber (one for cleaning dishes) instead of metal wool?
i have seen people using those with success, but i always wondered if they are much more rust resistant than steel wool, which means they would take longer. give it a try! =)
HI ltfi. I’ve used both ultra fine steel wool and the thicker steel pads used for cleaning pots. I find I get different shades with the different metal sources. (I use unfiltered cider vinegar as my base) I personally prefer the colors I’ve been getting with the pot scrubber pads. hth
It’s a nice technique. Appreciate a natural way of making wood stains and that’s also without chemicals, really good.
TAHANK YOU VERY VERY MUCH!! You save me!!
Hi, i used the vinigar and steel method however there are streak marks of how i applied it on the floor, colours is also a bit darker then what i wanted. What can i do or apply do lighter the colour to a lighter colour and get rid of the streak marks. Could i do it plain vinigar or even water? Urget reply would be much appreciated.
if you can gently sand the surface, that would be the best way. if not, try wash it with 1 part baking soda diluted in 5-10 parts water. always remember to test in future, because different types of wood react differently to the stains! =)
i tried rusty nails and steel wool. I waited several days because it didn’t look like anything wsa happening.
today was the big day. I brushed some on a piece of wood, and it was CLEAR! i was so disappointed.
I walked away and got the other jar, and when i got back, the spot was almost black. OOPS, it worked!
i then brushed several other boards, and they all came out different.
I’m very happy with the results, thanks.
Tomorrow, I’m going to dilute some white acrylic paint to white wash some boards. What we’re doing is finishing the walls of a garage with pallet wood; also a good source of more rusty nails!!
thanks!
your pallet wall sounds amazing mimi! i may quote you in this post because lots of people go through the “nothing is happening” moment! =)
I came across this post from Pinterest. So glad that I found it! I have used some unusual stains in the past. The one that I can think of right now is one that we used to make a corner table. I didn’t have any store stain that I wanted to use and I wanted to get this table in like YESTERDAY! I just happened to have a couple of boxes of old hair dye that I was getting ready to toss out. (It was so old that the plastic bottle was cracking!) I used it and I have to say it came out wonderful! I would have much rather not have used something that had had all those chemicals in it but I did use what I had a it didn’t go to the landfill.
I will be giving this a try though as my daughters have a couple of projects that need to be finished. Thanks for all of the pictures!
thank you for sharing this interesting idea Stahli! =)
I made a stain with way too much vinegar, but on the first piece of test wood ( pine ) it instantly got more saturated, and 30-60 minutes later it looked much darker and aged than to begin with.
However, when I brushed some more on the same piece of wood, just the other side, it didn’t do anything at all. Did I make a really inconsistent batch, or is my wood just assembled from different sorts?
Really loving the look of the stain that did turn out, though, so thank you for this article!
hi fred! i think it could be because the stain was very diluted. also i find some wood don’t react to stains, they will need a coat of strong tea first. =)
Does the smell go away?
yes, no more vinegar/metal smell after a couple of months
Hey,
This stain idea is great! I’ve been wanting to stain a bench that my nephew made for me ito compliment my laundry room decor. Now I know just what to do to get gray. Thanks for the info!
I followed these instructions exactly, except the part about taking the steel wool pads out. I stuck the jars somewhere out of sight intending to take the pads out after 24 hours and proceeded to completely forget about them. It’s been over a month and I’m uncertain about what to do, should I dump the vinegar down the drain and throw the jars away?
Hi! You can use this stain, it will likely be pretty dark! 🙂
Hi just wondering if i stain a bench seat, using vinegar and rusty nails, will it come off onto my clothing? Thanks.
hi sam, no it will not, the stain will be embedded.
just wipe off the bench a day after the stain dries because there might be a very fine dust on the surface.
I’m hoping you can help be troubleshoot what happened: I brewed some strong black tea and painted it on what I *think* is pine or birch plywood. Once it had dried, I painted it with the vinegar solution (the white vinegar with steel wool pad that had been sitting for 24+ hours). Every time I have tried it the stain has come out a light gray. I’ve tried it with and without the tea, I’ve used coffee instead of tea and every time it is gray. It’s a pretty color, but not at all the color I was going for. I was going for what you have pictured as the result of your #2. Also, the steel pad doesn’t seem to have dissolved like yours did. Any suggestions? Thanks!
hi kourtney, i think plywood might have additives such as adhesive between the thin layers that prevents a real reaction. one simple test is to try it on a piece of scrap wood or even white paper, the stain should give a deep brown color. =)
I have a question rather a comment. Since I like the steel wool stain best, would I have to remove the soap from the steel wool before placing it in the jar with the vinegar?
Hi! I would rinse or soak it in water first:)
just a little history….these stains (ferric acetate) have been used for centuries , on wood ,leather,steel,and cloth…I have a tip about dyeing cloth …saturate cloth with stain let sit but do not let it dry..then rinse it out…I tried it on fustion ( a cotton/linen mix) and got a beautiful golden/tan…these stains will not fade easily in sunlight.
Another variation is to use copper (but not pennies…too much zinc)wire cut-offs are good ,but to get best results the solution takes9-12 months to make a light blue stain…this solution was used to keep weevils,rats and mice from chewing on the wood or fabric and copper does have an antibacterial aspect also…have fun ,I have used these stains for years and am a furniture maker
thank you so much Mark for sharing! 🙂
Would this be safe to use on a raised vegetable garden? I am just wondering about the steel wool and if it could leach into the soil and end up in your vegetables.
yes it is safe! vinegar, iron rust or steel wool are all harmless to soil =)
Hi,
I’m just wondering if you have ever used this over a wood filler, (Specifically Minwax) and had any trouble with it accepting this stain.
hi erica,
any type of wood stain or finishing would create a layer that would reduce or eliminate the chemical reaction between the wood and these stains, except for recipe 7, which is diluted paint. =)
Oh, wow! So surprising how the stain develops on the wood after leaving for 10 minutes! My wife did a DIY stain project before and was so pissed she threw in the bin! Will let her know to wait for a couple of minutes next time.